|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Eurovision fans barely had time to digest their breakfast before social media exploded with fresh controversy: the semi-final results might be getting a dramatic new makeover — and not everyone’s applauding.
After days of speculation, a still from Der Weg zum ESC 2025, a behind-the-scenes documentary aired by Swiss broadcaster SRF, appears to confirm a major change to how qualifiers will be announced during this year’s semi-finals in Basel. Instead of the familiar “ten envelopes” format that has kept viewers clutching their cushions and pearls for some time, the new system seems to involve a more theatrical — and arguably crueler — approach.
Leaked image
The leaked image, shared via ESC Discord on X/Twitter, shows part of a script suggesting that three countries will be spotlighted before only one is confirmed as a qualifier.
That means two unlucky artists — already exhausted and emotionally spent — will be visibly, publicly denied a place in the Grand Final. And given the number of entrants, some acts would see themselves ‘shortlisted’ more than once. And ruled out more than once.
It’s the Eurovision equivalent of Deal or No Deal, with extra trauma, but thankfully less in the way of Noel Edmunds.
Savage
While EBU has yet to officially confirm the change, reaction online has been swift — and largely negative.
“This feels like manufactured drama at the expense of the artists,” one Reddit user wrote. “They’re turning the semi-final into a talent show elimination night.”
Others pointed out the unnecessary cruelty of giving false hope to performers who’ve already laid their souls bare in front of millions. “It’s not entertainment — it’s humiliation,” tweeted one fan, adding: “This isn’t The X Factor.”
Eurovision needs moments
Of course, not everyone is against the idea. Some argue that, with the show’s ever-growing run time and competition for global attention, anything that increases suspense could boost engagement.
“It’s savage, yes. But people will talk about it. And Eurovision needs moments,” said one long-time blogger.
Still, for a contest rooted in unity and celebration, the shift feels out of step. The semi-final envelope reveal has always offered a rare blend of tension and kindness: moments of joy without rubbing salt in the wounds of those who miss out. This new format risks swapping empathy for spectacle.
As we await official clarification from the EBU, one thing is certain — if this change goes ahead, Eurovision 2025 will be as unforgettable as ever. For better or worse.