LIVE BLOG: Eurovision 2019 – Second semi-final

Hosts of Eurovision 2019

Were you ready for the second bunch of Eurovision 2019 hopefuls? Tonight we got 18 songs, and they scored the remaining ten grand final slots.

I was on hand to walk you through the finer points of what happened on stage and you were welcome to join in with comments. We had such fun together on Tuesday, after all.

Click to see the line-up for tonight
SongPerformer(s)Psn
Like meSeleste6
StayDriksna9
I will break your heartKatrina Bindere8
TridymiteEdgars Kreilis7
Heart beatsKatrina Dimanta2
I'm falling for youMiks Dukurs4
PolyesterAnnna3
Sail with youBad Habits5
Still breathingSamanta Tina1

There were just three places left in the second half of the running order, and we’ll be getting more about that later tonight.

May 12, 2025 15:38
ENDED
Latest update 2 months ago
22:24
Wrap up

So they showed all of the qualifiers in the new style and, to be honest, it made zero difference to me as to what they showed on screen - what was funny was that they banished Osterdahl to a bunker and he never said a word!

The on-screen graphics are clear and concise and they are all going to show a clip of each of the finalists - it's probably half of a recap's worth which is going to be plenty I reckon.  

The hosts then wrap it up by introducing Jorgen Olsen singing a lullaby to send us off.  It's a reworking of FOTWOL without his brother (which I don't like to be honest) but its not my choice!

And thats everything, I too am going to get a stiff frunk and head to my bed.   Thanks for visiting and see you tomorrow!

Phil Colclough
22:14
Martin watch

They have hidden him in a production bunker and he was not allowed to speak!

Now we get the new voting reveal and I think I like it.   They focus on three countries at a time and they put one through.  No song will be shown more than three times - I reckon that the mathematicians have been out in force.   To be honest - It looks hardly any different to be honest. 

Phil Colclough
22:09
Green Room shenanigans......

Gifts for delegations,  interviews by Sandra and Hazel.  This segment could go horribly wrong!

"It doesn't matter what you say now, the commentators will talk all over us" as they get KAJ to pull faces.  

Phil Colclough
22:03
Celine update

Celine is doing a video message in French and English, of course - seems as though she is not going to be here after all - so the redtops in the Eurovision were all incorrect after all.  (and she is still looking ill)

They then cut to the stage with an plethora of Eurovision acts of the past singing Ne Partez Pas sans moi and the Neues Orchestra Basel accompanying them on stage.  

Is is wrong to say this could have been Scott Fitzgerald being sung at?!?

Phil Colclough
21:58
More Business...........

They are just talking words now the voting have been closed  - specifically about Records, showing a bit of old contests etc....

Then they move to the most streamed songs in history. 

If, like me, you are waiting to see if the crowd boo Martin Osterdahl or hide him in a bunker, your wait is almost over!

Phil Colclough
21:54
STOP VOTING

For once they almost got it right by hardly missing the countdown!

Phil Colclough
21:52
Once more with shorter clips

the final recap now....

I wonder how they are going to mangle the voting countdown?

Phil Colclough
21:47
Well

I liked it
The crowd in the auditorium liked it

That's all that counts.   

Next a video of the opening ceremony 

Phil Colclough
21:44
Oh I like this!

What's *she* doing here?!

Phil Colclough
21:43
Switzerland's history in Eurovision

Well, sort of.  

They actually getting Sandra to sing in the middle bit.  well, mime.  It's about Swiss cliches! - I have a feeling it's called Made in Switzerland!

It's also less cloying than the Swedish version of this in the last few years.  

Phil Colclough
21:40
Recap Time

They have been showing us the recap so they also might keep us on for the interval - stay tuned

Phil Colclough
21:34
Phil's final ranking after all Fifteen songs

Sweden

Belgium

Poland

Albania

Slovenia

Azerbaijan

The Netherlands

Iceland

San Marino

Cyprus

Norway

Croatia

Estonia

Ukraine

Portugal

Phil Colclough
21:33
Cyprus

One final song of the evening - well competing anyway - and that is Cyprus with the older than they make him look Theo Evan singing "shhh" - where do you think you are, Wimbledon?!

Anyhow, remember how we mentioned that Red Sebastian will be playing in the clubs of Ibiza? - There is every chance tha tthis will be played in Agia Napa in mid July.  

My problem with this is that the scaffolding poles that are on stage are clearly being played with to distract the viewer from the song which has lyrics which are undecipherable at a speed quick enough for a televoter to "get" the song.  I mean take nothing away, they are very impressive scaffolding poles and the holders are quite hunky but it's not the Eurovision Dance contest because they seem to have left their song at home!

Phil Colclough
21:29
One final big five songs

Well, technically, Switzerland. 

As she's from Basel, and because I am not there, they clearly sent her back home, steering a ship down the canal, it's hardly the Trent and Mersey, I grant you that!

It's a lovely song and will get a massive cheer when it comes on stage tomorrow night and on Saturday but like most French language songs it suffers from the "too many words to say the simpliest thing" syndrome - couple that with it not being televoter friendly when compared to other things that are going to be in the final then it's going to be competing for jury votes and, again, they might be a little bit thin here. 

Switzerland will be lower right hand side and people wont understand why.  ooh and in the hall, remember to use your lights cos they will have asked you to.  

Phil Colclough
21:24
Croatia

Red and green should never be seen except upon a fool but Marko is no fool.  He's just too goth for this contest unfortunately.  He is a great performer but he is better than this song or, more accurately three or four songs which have been duct taped together to get to the three minute limit here.   The best bit of the song is the bridge into the end bit of the song but by then the listener will have gone "What the actual actual IS this" and nipped off to the loo. 

It was the best in the DORA which says they had learned nothing.   

Phil Colclough
21:20
Netherlands

The Dutch are up next and Claude is up in the mountains on a train.

This song is a gamble.  It relies almost totally on Claude's voice  which is definitely there but I don't get the mix of languages or where they are put in the song which for a first time listener could well confuse them.   What does it have for them to pick the phone up and vote for it, well a good beat to the song which makes your shoulders go up and down. 

When he gets to the last bit of the song his voice is a little bit wavy but I think that has been documented in other places in worse terms than that.  

Honestly I think this is struggling but not because it's bad - because who is it aimed at?

Phil Colclough
21:16
Albania

Some people's idea of the winner next and, honestly, I can't see that happening in a million years.   Another red staging with the addition of white light boxes on the stage in the shape of an "X". 

I don't get the hype here - I mean yes, it's a decent song performed as only a song from Albania can be, namely by a shouty woman but with added white haired beardy man for contrast.   I've heard this a million times from Albania but what makes it different to them is that it's not overdone too much.  

Should qualify. 

Phil Colclough
21:12
Phil's ranking after Eleven songs

Sweden

Belgium

Poland

Slovenia

Azerbaijan

Iceland

San Marino

Norway

Estonia

Ukraine

Portugal

Phil Colclough
21:11
San Marino

A pregnant pause as they get Gabry's DJ booth set up on stage and they fill it with shots of the crowd, cos there is nothing else to fill it up with!

Gabry's name is on this song but its only in name only cos his two masked singers and the three at the front of the stage that the camera tries to avoid are doing all the singing - he's just doing the hand movements that a DJ does. 

If you are not sick of this after Sanremo you'll be sick of it after one run through of the verse and chorus cos it plays all its cards then.   Not a sniff of San Marino a song called " All Italy"

Phil Colclough
21:07
Azerbaijan

Dear Fyr og Flamme - *this* is how you do the genre without actually wanting me to slap you.  The boys don't look slappable and know how to do the retro sound quite well.  The falsetto notes are good and the production on stage is very.... red. 

Also, the background to the singers in parts reminds me of the intro to the muppet show, specifically the end bit of it.  

This should be qualifying easily - that'll piss twitter off!

Phil Colclough
21:03
Interval business

it's about props on stage - or not - thankfully Stripper, the best worst song of all time, gets shown

Phil Colclough
21:00
Italy

One of the big 5 to entertain us now, specifically Italy whom they have put on a very old tram!.

I tell you what I don't like about this song, is that it has subtitles on the screen where none of the other non-english language songs do.... is that what they pay for?

This song does ooze class though I have to admit it and Lucio is the showiest showman that ever showed and if you end up thinking "Wasn't he in the Ukrainian band a few minutes ago" no, but he could fit in there and they could fit in here, if they had the talent. 

It's a cross between Bowie, Mercury and Sanremo that is getting people excited.  It's not bad but it's not winning.  

And he's not playing the mouth organ, no matter how much he may look like it!

Phil Colclough
20:56
Phil's ranking after NINE songs

Sweden

Belgium

Poland

Slovenia

Iceland

Norway

Estonia

Ukraine

Portugal

Phil Colclough
20:55
Belgium

For his postcard SSR have unironically taken Red Sebastian up the Jungfrau!

The difference between this and Norway can't be overstated.  This is what you get when you put an experienced performer on a stage singing a half decent song and then tell them they are going to be singing it in the biggest gay club in the world.   

This has got the crowd clapping along and, again, the difference in stage presence between the last two acts is pronounced because Red, as I am calling him, knows exactly where to step and where to look and if he doesn't, it wouldn't phase him. 

NG1 or your national equivalent will be playing this for months, as will the clubs in Ibiza.  Very good indeed that.  

Phil Colclough
20:51
Norway

Norway next and a teenager acting out some very specific fantasies on stage.   This one too is about losing his mother, but why the earth he's in chainmail and armour I never know...

Kyle seemingly is having problems singing his own song because he sounds unsure and very weak on the higher notes, so much so I went "oh my god" when he tried them for the first time and as soon as he goes anything higher than his standard range it's almost like he is singing in a key that only dogs can hear.   

This song was paper thin to start with with it's daft lyrics but this is just not good.  He'll be told that it's all fine and dandy, it's not.  It's noticeable to anyone that is going to be listening 

Phil Colclough
20:47
Phil's actual ranking after Seven songs

Sweden

Poland

Slovenia

Iceland

Estonia

Ukraine

Portugal

Phil Colclough
20:46
Portugal

So after all that Sauna and sweat inducing dancing round stage I bet you could do with a nap?

Enter Portugal, Nytol set to music! - Jesus Christ this song is hideous and even your lead singer shouting "Vamos" isn't helping this one. 

I just don't know who this is going to appeal to apart from the insomniacs around Europe.   Sorry but no.   

Phil Colclough
20:43
Sweden

For the first time in a few years I have goosebumps from the start here. 

The vocal seems a bit off and/or light in the intro but they soon get that back when they start doing all the prancing about.   You can hear the crowd screaming when they are singing this but SSR seem to have to have muted the sound but even with that you can hear the clapping coming through your speakers. 

There are flames going all over the place which whips the crowd up even more and when they get into the final chorus carnage breaks out. 

Tomorrow night, as Richard from Eurovision Ireland quite rightly said at the MF Final "If this doesn't qualify there is going to be a fucking riot"

Love love love love - but could be performed better.....

Phil Colclough
20:39
Phil's Ranking after 5 songs

Poland

Slovenia

Iceland

Estonia

Ukraine

Phil Colclough
20:38
Ukraine

Eastward now to Ukraine and more cliches ahoy as the cheese fondue comes out because of course it would!

The best thing I can say about this song is that it is a Ukrainan song for Ukranian people that clearly missed out on David Bowie's Ziggy Stardust phase.  If any of you have seen their selection show, the garden carpet at the front of the stage has been disguarded

To me the lead singer's voice went a bit wobbly at the end of the second verse but lets put that down to the stream shall we? - Well no, let's not because when he goes into the next bridge he is slightly off to my ear. 

They are struggling with this one. 

Phil Colclough
20:34
First Big Five - Spain

OK - the winner of our countdown comes next and they have shipped her off to Lucerne for the day, in the rain to make Chocolate.  Jesus it's the Eurovision Cliché contest!

A click of the castanets and we're off   and Melody gets the audience going some and the first quick change goes well and I have to drudgingly admit that I like this song, but that could be the gay boy in me screaming to get out.  The whole song is great and just flows really well.   

It's also staged immaculately as well with the deep stage showing this off to the fullest.  Yeah, this is going to do alright you know!

Phil Colclough
20:29
Swiss songs that took on the World

Apparently DJ Bobo is not on the stage but I suspect he will be tomorrow.

Yellow and The Race are next......  You'll know it when you hear it!

Most iconic song ever - sold 50 million records and apparently has a dance... it's the Birdie song...

No, i'm not doing the dance - get that picture out of your heads immediately you filthy swines!

Can we get back to the music now?!

Phil Colclough
20:26
Estonia

Well this is three minutes of Cholera isn't it?

Even from the postcard where Tommy is at a roller rink I wish that someone would have "done him a mischief" and put Europe out of their misery. 

He sings in front of a set that says "Winners Cafe" and in the first chorus, or what passes for it, it sounds like his mic has slipped but sadly for the rest of us it's back by the first verse.

For me, this is an unfunny three minute piss take  and it just goes on way too long and any slight smerk faded about 20 seconds in and I hope it gets the result it actually deserves rather than the one I fear it is going to get.  

the Crowd loved it - they are simpletons!

Phil Colclough
20:22
Slovenia

Get your hankies out - Klemen is going to rip your heart out. 

A deeply personal song showing home videos to the crowd on the background and him not knowing how much time his wife has left.  thankfully for all concerned she didn't die, she survives to join him on the stage.  

He does the upside down thing which seems to be symbolic of his life at that time and that in itself is powerful but this is not a contest song in my opinion but it could well sneak in 10th place but I can't see it getting much higher and for a song like this, that is criminal.  

And yes, I'm crying at the middle eight and when his wife comes onto stage.  So sue me!

Phil Colclough
20:18
Poland

At first when it came on I forgot what it was cos I was not concentrating on the screen but I should have remembered as soon as she opened her mouth.   

This is more the type of thing Albania are known for rather than conservative Poland and it gets the crowd going with the gymnastics and the screaming.   Better than Iceland, but that's faint praise.  

A long shot of the hall follows as they get her kit off stage. 

Phil Colclough
20:13
Iceland

So the laddy bantz has gone away and the boys from Iceland are up first. 

I love this song and I can't think why cos it has nothing going for it.  The boys seem to be holding back and for the first time ever they actually lift their shades so you can see their childlike faces.   

The crowd seem to like it and thats all you can ask for.    They also recreate the boat from the national final but the graphics are from Roblox, or a ZX Spectrum, not sure which. 

At the end of the song they all come to the front of the stage.  It makes me smile, but it's a long damn three minutes!  I also suppect the backing singers on tape are doing a lot of the heavy lifting here!

Phil Colclough
20:08
Continental knockabout

Oh there is some knockabout bantz between the two hosts that is not really working as far as I can tell....  Can we get on with the songs now?

Phil Colclough
20:06
Hosts

After a bit of mishearing - we're seeing our hosts. 

Sandra needs some styling och consulting advice cos she is in a fucking hideous yellow trouser suit and Hazel is in an equally hideous jacket.

Dear SSR - NO!

Phil Colclough
20:03
Isn't the stage lovely

something we would only say when things det despirate but tonight the set actually *is* lovely.. I'm told it's very deep and the TV Screen arch belies how big the arena is.

A shot of the crowd and it's quote busy, in fact it looks full.  On stage there are people yoiking..... it smells of cheese in here as well - perhaps that's the local flavour coming through the screen?!

Phil Colclough
20:01
And we're off

to a first time start I believe - the Grand National has nothing on the EBU.....

A nice faux intro screen before blacked out screens reveal two dancers on the floor.  I presume this is a bit about Switzerland rising out of the sea or something.   It's all very dark and moody and here come the Alphorns!

Phil Colclough
19:58
Sound *and* Vision

Apparently there is both in the press centre - online all we have is a countdown clock.... just about 90 seconds to go. 

Phil Colclough
19:55
Five minutes to go

So i'm waiting patiently for the live stream to come on line in the press centre at OnEurope towers.... i'm hoping for a good show!

Phil Colclough
19:38
So here is your 23 minute claxon - no sorry - alpenhorn

It's all going to kick off at the top of the hour!

Phil Colclough
24 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Prediction time:

I have a small problem with this semi. I can’t see all Scandi countries qualifying.
Last year they were also in the same semi and managed to qualify, all of them. But last year was a much weaker semi than this year.
As Sweden is definitely qualifying, I have to figure out between Norway and Denmark.
Than there is the question whether I should go with the 5/5 split or the 4/6 split.
Another issue is what to do with Austria – personally I love the song and from what I read, they managed to make song works in a staging that just sell the song.

In short the prediction below, or at least part of it, is not going to happen:

Switzerland
Romania
Sweden
Austria
Malta
Russia
Norway
The Netherlands
North Macedonia
Azerbaijan

Denmark may sneak in instead of one of the above.

Enjoy the show

Mo Fanning
6 years ago
Reply to  ShaiD.

It’s the same here, with 6-7 I think will make it, and 5 maybes

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Armenia + fine vocals but having her alone on stage is wrong.
Also a questionable fashion choice.
She looks desperate

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Ireland – I like the pop-art vibe of this but can we have a better song.
It’s just a forgettable song that lacks of energy

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Moldova – old fashioned ballad and she is off key, sometimes. I think her backing singers are helping her a bit

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Switzerland -he is the male Eleni. The whole performance scream Fuego, with a little less passion.
He is a bit breathy, but he is doing just fine

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Latvia – a perfect lounge music. That says it all about it chances. Musically not a bad song, just not enough for this competition

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Denmark – it’s almost childish and very sweet but it is also very calculated.
Is there a hidden backing singer?

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Austria – this utlize the stage in right way.
Not sure if this strong enough to go through, though

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Malta – this is cool. It works to a certain level. She is a bit static for the song, but she should qualify

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Lithuania – I just had my toilet break.
Rule 2525 of Eurovision is that you are not allowed to be boring

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Russia – he is starting off key and too low in the mix.
And the staging is a let down. Bring You Are the only one back, which I never like. Show you how much I dislike this one

AndrewMcG
AndrewMcG
6 years ago

Russia – Sergey and Co have been channelling Chess the musical … just not as well.

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Albania – is too dark and not working, no matter how ethnics it sounds.
Vocally is this just not good.
Apparently the collums at the side of the stage can move

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Norway – who thought that placing them on 3 side of the stage was a good idea?
Now they are together but there is no chemistry between them.
And that bridge is a miss

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

The Netherlands – too many wide shots.
But he performed it well although not giving you the goosebumps the song gave me at first listen

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

North Macedonia – a classic Eurovision ballad. She sing it well and they didn’t bricked the staging up.
She sings this well

Darren Smith
6 years ago

I found both Sweden and Netherlands (who I had predicted as 1 and 2 respectively in this semi) quite underwhelming. Russia too. It wouldn’t surprise me if Switzerland have won this semi?

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

Azerbaijan – it lacks some of the energy from the video and Hiden backing singers were doing some of the singing for him

Darren Smith
6 years ago

My predicted qualifiers are the same as Mo’s (I’ve not changed my 10 since before the contest started but I’ve changed the order a bit).
Netherlands
Azerbaijan
Sweden
Switzerland
Russia
Denmark
Malta
Norway
North Macedonia
Armenia

I don’t rate Netherlands that much but it was probably tonight’s winner. Australia FTW on Saturday.

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

After watching the performances, I don’t think Romania is qualifying and Denmark are but I am less certain about Norway and Austria

ShaiD.
ShaiD.
6 years ago

8/10 – missing on Albania and Denmark.

All Scandi are through, which I didn’t think will be possible.
3/7 split – Can’t remember the last time this happened.
Last 6 songs performed have qualified

Darren Smith
6 years ago

9/10, and I so almost swapped out Armenia for Albania! (Armenia were my 10th place prediction)

Jim Walsh
6 years ago

Got 9 out of 10 – really did not see Albania qualifying (I had Romania in the last place but it was a bit of a guess to be honest). Like Darren below I was very underwhelmed with both Sweden and Netherlands and just don’t understand where the hype is coming from on these two. Russia was well-performed but is as cold and calculated as a song can be. Be fun to see him come third again in the final! Actually the surprise of the night for me was North Macedonia which came across as a solid well-sung if unspectacular song.

I’ve been very underwhelmed with both semi-finals to be honest. Australia has been my favourite since it was picked (because I’m a sucker for popera) and with the staging now I hope it goes all the way. Especially as it will annoy the bejesus out of Phil if it wins!!! 😉

But then I was the same about Israel and Cyprus last year and don’t get started on that rubbish from Portugal in 2017. Clearly the public/juries/fans of Eurovision and I have had a parting of the ways in the last few years.